McCaffrey's Food Market - Newtown at 2890 South Eagle Road, Newtown, Pennsylvania.

This is by far the best supermarket in the area. There isn't even a close second. Their produce is always the freshest, the butcher department is amazing, and the Deli product is as good as it gets in a supermarket. Well run, always clean, very courteous people working there. Price is very fair for the high quality.

I want to like Mcaffreys, I really do. It's clean, aesthetically pleasing, and their prepared food section seems to be on point. Overall it's a little expensive, but I get that quality food stores often are.

Today I got some chicken dumplings, and after eating one and starting on my second, I noticed that the chicken was significantly undercooked, as in still noticably pink and rubbery. Not wanting anyone to get sick, I drove back to the store to return the dumplings and inform management. Now, in my former experience in the food industry, I always learned to take undercooked chicken, and in general, improperly prepared food seriously, and to go into overdrive on customer service regarding this. No such treatment. I was polite with the manager, but let him know I took this kind of thing seriously and was a little worried about getting sick. I got my money back, but no apology, or even an appearance of concern. At my urging he got someone to remove the existing dumplings. Sorry guys, I wanted to like you but I'm moving on.

Despite that, two stars, because otherwise my experience there has been pretty positive